Big Buddy or Hunting Buddy heater for a big shelter

Each is a Mr. Heater radiant model that shuts itself off on low oxygen or a tip, and each can be fed from a 20 lb tank set outdoors. The Big Buddy goes to 18,000 BTU, the Hunting Buddy stops at 12,000, and that gap decides most of this match.

Big hub or wheelhouse, Big Buddy; mid-size hub, Hunting Buddy

The Big Buddy is the larger tool. Mr. Heater rates it at up to 18,000 BTU and 450 sq ft, against 12,000 BTU and 300 sq ft for the Hunting Buddy, so a crowded hub or a wheelhouse-style shelter points to the bigger box.

Pick the Mr. Heater Big Buddy if your shelter is large and you already haul a 20 lb tank. Pick the Mr. Heater Hunting Buddy for a mid-size hub, where one cylinder and a single setting jump cover the day.

Both sit on our ice fishing heater shortlist, the Big Buddy as pick 2 and the Hunting Buddy as pick 5. The Hunting Buddy also meets the storage-bay FLEX in Buddy FLEX or Hunting Buddy.

The two Mr. Heater models side by side

Mr. Heater’s manuals and product pages supply most numbers, with store listings filling the gaps the maker leaves. The Hunting Buddy column flags every figure we could not confirm.

FeatureMr. Heater Big BuddyMr. Heater Hunting Buddy
Heat output4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU/hr6,000 or 12,000 BTU/hr
Rated areaUp to 450 sq ftUp to 300 sq ft
Fuel and cylindersOne or a pair of 1 lb cylinders, or one or a pair of 20 lb tanks outdoors on Buddy hosesA single 1 lb cylinder, or a single outdoor 20 lb tank by hose
Run time per 1 lb1.5 to 6 hours on one cylinder (low and medium only), 3 to 12 hours on two1.5 to 3.5 hours, high to low
Run time per 20 lb tank24 to 108 hours36 to 72 hours
IgnitionPiezo, no batteriesBattery pulse ignition, 1 × AA
SafetyODS plus tip-over cut-off, ANSI Z21.103Same two shut-offs, CSA 4.98
Vent needed18 sq in at the ceiling and at floor level12 sq in per the spec page (troubleshooting page says 9)
Weight17.1 lb per Mr. Heater (some listings say 13)About 16 lb on retailer listings, possibly the shipping weight
Price band$$, some retailers list it above $180$$, our estimate
Warranty3 years limited (product page), 1 year (policy page)Could not confirm

18,000 BTU against 12,000 in a big shelter

On high, the Big Buddy puts out half again as much heat as the Hunting Buddy. It also idles lower, at 4,000 BTU against 6,000, which helps on a mild afternoon when the Hunting Buddy’s low step can still run too warm.

Bar chart of the rated heating area of the five ice fishing heaters in square feet
Rated heating areas from the makers assume a closed, insulated space. On open ice in the wind, a fabric shelter needs more heat than the label suggests.

Owners say the Big Buddy on high keeps a large hub at shirt-sleeve comfort. Our BTU and shelter size guide does the sizing arithmetic, and the shelter types guide matches heater size to hubs and permanent shacks.

Round goes to the Big Buddy, for the bigger top end and the gentler low.

Two cylinders or one, then a tank outside

The Big Buddy takes two 1 lb cylinders. On a single one, Mr. Heater’s Buddy FAQ says it runs low and medium only and the manual gives 1.5 to 6 hours, while two cylinders unlock high and stretch that to 3 to 12 hours.

The Hunting Buddy takes one 1 lb cylinder for 1.5 to 3.5 hours. A pound of propane holds roughly 21,600 BTU, so no heater burning 12,000 BTU or more lasts long on a single small cylinder.

That is why most owners of either heater move to a 20 lb tank kept outside the shelter. The manuals give 24 to 108 hours per tank for the Big Buddy and 36 to 72 hours for the Hunting Buddy, and the Big Buddy can draw from two tanks.

Both use the same Buddy hoses, and the filter-free F273704 is the simple choice. Our 20 lb tank setup guide covers the hookup and the leak check.

Round goes to the Big Buddy, for the second cylinder port and the longer tank range.

Below 20 °F on the ice

The two manuals share one caution. Burn either heater nonstop below 20 °F and run times shrink fast, which is why Mr. Heater steers you toward a 20 lb tank in that cold.

Propane boils at about −44 °F, and as a small cylinder chills under heavy draw its pressure sags and frost forms on the steel. Our guide on why 1 lb cylinders fade explains it step by step.

The Big Buddy has a slight edge on cylinders, since two of them share the draw. In deep cold the cure is the same for both heaters, a 20 lb tank outside on a hose, and both may also shut off above 7,000 ft.

Round goes to the Big Buddy by a small margin.

Venting 18 or 12 square inches

Each has an oxygen depletion sensor (ODS) and a switch that kills the flame if the heater falls, and both manuals list fishing huts among approved enclosures. The Big Buddy cites ANSI Z21.103 and the Hunting Buddy CSA 4.98. On paper, the safety hardware matches.

The difference is the fresh air each one asks for. The Big Buddy manual wants 18 sq in at the ceiling and again at floor level. The Hunting Buddy spec page asks for 12 sq in, though its troubleshooting page says 9, so plan on the larger figure.

Because an ODS responds to thin air rather than to CO, the Minnesota DNR warns anglers not to trust it alone. Mount a battery CO alarm, brush drifted snow off the vents and never sleep with either heater lit. Our venting guide sizes the openings.

Leave the clearance the Buddy manuals specify, 30 in overhead and 24 in ahead of the burner, and keep either heater well away from fabric walls and bags.

A draw, though the Big Buddy needs more vent area.

Weight, ignition and the missing fan

Mr. Heater lists the Big Buddy at 17.1 lb, though some listings say 13 lb. The Hunting Buddy shows about 16 lb on retailer listings, which may be the shipping weight, so the two may be closer in heft than their output suggests.

The current Big Buddy, model F274805, has no fan. Owner complaints about fan noise and battery drain refer to older units with a D-battery blower, and the new one lights by piezo with no batteries.

The Hunting Buddy uses pulse ignition on one AA cell, so pack a spare. Hunters like its fold-down handle, and owners describe quiet, steady heat. Big Buddy owners add that wind or an open door can blow out the pilot.

A draw, battery-free lighting on one side and a handier handle on the other.

Price band and value

Both sit in the $$ band of $100 to $180. The Hunting Buddy band is our estimate, and some retailers list the Big Buddy above $180, so check the live listing before you order.

For a big shelter, the Big Buddy gives more heat for similar money. The Hunting Buddy earns its place in a mid-size hub, where 18,000 BTU would mostly warm the air leaving through the vents. The Portable Buddy and FLEX comparison covers the next step down.

Round goes to the Big Buddy on value for a big shelter.

The Hunting Buddy has the thinnest paper trail of the five. Its warranty is not confirmed and its price band is our estimate, and its own manual gives two vent figures, so read the listing and plan for 12 sq in.

The Big Buddy’s catch is fuel. On high it empties 1 lb cylinders fast, and most owners end up hauling a 20 lb tank and hose onto the ice.

Sized to your shelter

For a large hub or a wheelhouse-style shelter, the Big Buddy is the one to take, ideally fed from a 20 lb tank outside. For a mid-size hub on one cylinder, the Hunting Buddy covers the middle step well.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Big Buddy and the Hunting Buddy

Which heats a bigger ice shelter, the Big Buddy or the Hunting Buddy?

The Big Buddy. Mr. Heater rates it at up to 18,000 BTU and 450 sq ft, against 12,000 BTU and 300 sq ft for the Hunting Buddy. For a large hub or a wheelhouse-style shelter, the bigger heater has the reserve you need on windy days.

Will one 1 lb cylinder let the Big Buddy reach high?

No. With a single small cylinder, Mr. Heater’s Buddy FAQ limits it to low and medium. To unlock high, fit a second 1 lb cylinder or hose in a tank of up to 20 lb from outside the shelter.

Does the current Big Buddy have a fan?

No. The current F274805 model is fanless, since Mr. Heater dropped the blower from some Big Buddy versions. Older units had a blower on D batteries, and reviews that mention fan noise or battery drain refer to those.

How much venting does each heater need?

The Big Buddy manual asks for 18 sq in at the ceiling and at floor level. The Hunting Buddy spec page says 12 sq in, though its troubleshooting page says 9, so plan on 12 and add a battery CO alarm.

Is the Hunting Buddy cheaper than the Big Buddy?

Both fall in the $$ band of $100 to $180, though the Hunting Buddy band is our estimate and some retailers list the Big Buddy above $180. Check the live listing, since prices move often.