Mr. Heater Big Buddy heater, 18,000 BTU for the big hub
The Big Buddy is the heater for anglers whose shelter has outgrown a Portable Buddy. It puts out twice the heat on high and asks for twice the venting. We did not run one ourselves, so this review sets Mr. Heater’s manual against what owners report, including the fan that the current model no longer has.
For big hubs
Our verdict
The Big Buddy is the heater to pick when a large hub or a shack needs more warmth than 9,000 BTU can give. Three settings let you warm the shelter fast and then turn it down, and a 20 lb tank outside keeps it fed for a full day. The current F274805 has no fan, so owner reviews about fan noise and battery drain describe older units. It is heavy, thirsty on high and needs 18 sq in of vent at the ceiling and at floor level.
Strengths
- 4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU, rated for up to 450 sq ft
- Runs one or two 1 lb cylinders or one or two 20 lb tanks
- ODS, tip-over switch and ANSI Z21.103, fishing huts in the manual
- Fanless current model needs no batteries
- Doubles as a garage or power-outage heater
Weaknesses
- About 17.1 lb and bulky to carry onto the ice
- High needs two 1 lb cylinders or a bigger tank
- Burns through 1 lb cylinders fast on high
- No fan, so heat pools near the roof of a tall hub
- Price can stray into the $$$ band at some retailers
Buy it if
you fish from a large hub or a semi-permanent shack, run a 20 lb tank anyway and want three heat settings with plenty in reserve.
Skip it if
you walk out with a small flip-over, want a light heater for 1 lb cylinders, or will not cut two proper vents.
Specs: Mr. Heater Big Buddy MH18B
| Type | Portable radiant propane heater, ceramic burner |
|---|---|
| Model | Current F274805 has no fan (older Big Buddy units had a battery fan) |
| Heat output | 4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU/hr |
| Rated heating area | Up to 450 sq ft per Mr. Heater |
| Fuel | One or two 1 lb cylinders, or one or two tanks up to 20 lb kept outside on Buddy hoses |
| High setting | Needs two 1 lb cylinders or a bigger tank (one 1 lb cylinder runs low and medium only) |
| Run time | One 1 lb cylinder 1.5 to 6 hours, two 1 lb cylinders 3 to 12 hours, one 20 lb tank 24 to 108 hours (manual) |
| Ignition | Piezo igniter |
| Safety | Low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch, ANSI Z21.103 camp-heater listing; the manual lists fishing huts |
| Fresh-air vent needed | 18 sq in at the ceiling and at floor level per the manual |
| Cold weather | Run time drops sharply below 20 °F; 20 lb tank recommended |
| Altitude | May shut off above 7,000 ft |
| Weight | 17.1 lb per Mr. Heater (some listings say 13 lb) |
| Not sold for | Massachusetts and Canada |
| Warranty | 3-year limited on the product page (policy page: 1 year) |
Data from the manufacturer’s manual and product page and from US retailers. Price band $$: $100 to $180. Only the price Amazon shows at checkout counts.
18,000 BTU for big hubs and shacks
Mr. Heater rates the Big Buddy at 4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU and up to 450 sq ft. That is twice the top output and rated area of the Portable Buddy, and the most heat of the five heaters we compare.
Owners say the high setting keeps a large hub warm enough for shirt sleeves, and many also use it in garages or during power outages. In a small flip-over it is far too much, and its medium setting already equals a Portable Buddy on high.
The three settings are the point. You can start on high to chase the chill out of a cold shelter, then drop to 9,000 or 4,000 BTU once the walls and the ice stop pulling heat away.
The current Big Buddy has no fan
The Big Buddy sold now, SKU F274805, has no fan, and the “NF” in its Amazon listing title stands for exactly that. Mr. Heater says it removed the fan from some Big Buddy models because of tariff changes.
Older units, including the F274800 and the Big Buddy Pro, had a blower that ran on D batteries or a 6V adapter. Owner reviews that mention fan noise or batteries draining in the cold refer to those older heaters, not to the one on sale today.
Losing the fan removes the noise and the battery worry, but it also means less air circulation. Heat collects under the roof of a tall hub, so aim the burner at the seats and expect the floor to stay cooler.
Some older listings may still show the fan version. Check for “NF” or F274805 on the listing so you know which heater you are getting.
Fuel and run time, two cylinders or two tanks
The Big Buddy takes one or two 1 lb cylinders, or one or two tanks up to 20 lb each on Buddy hoses. Per Mr. Heater’s Buddy FAQ, a single 1 lb cylinder runs low and medium only, and high needs two cylinders or a bigger tank.
The manual quotes 1.5 to 6 hours on one 1 lb cylinder and 3 to 12 hours on two. One 20 lb tank gives 24 to 108 hours and two give 48 to 216, with the long figures on the low setting.
Arithmetic shows why owners call it thirsty. Two 1 lb cylinders hold roughly 44,000 BTU of propane between them, so at 18,000 BTU they last about two and a half hours.
That is why most owners leave the cylinders at home and park a 20 lb tank outside the shelter wall. Mr. Heater tests the Buddy line up to 20 lb tanks and does not recommend anything larger.
On the hose side, Mr. Heater’s 10 ft F273704 works without a filter, and its 5 ft and 12 ft hoses call for the F273699 filter. Our guide to running a heater off a 20 lb tank covers the hookup step by step.
Cold-weather performance on 1 lb cylinders
The manual repeats the Buddy-line warning that nonstop running below 20 °F shortens run times significantly, and it points you to a 20 lb tank. Small cylinders chill as they feed the burner, lose pressure and frost over.
With 18,000 BTU on demand, this heater draws vapor faster than any other Buddy, so a pair of 1 lb cylinders feels the cold sooner. A big tank outside holds its pressure far better through a long, frigid day.
Like the rest of the line, it may shut off above 7,000 ft. On most hard-water lakes that limit never comes into play.
Lighting and controls
A piezo igniter sits on the control valve, so lighting takes no matches and, on the fanless model, no batteries at all. You light the pilot first, then step up through low, medium and high.
Owners report the weak spot shared by every Buddy. Wind or an opened shack door can blow out the pilot, and the gas then shuts off, so keep the burner away from the door and out of drafts.
Safety features and venting 18,000 BTU
The Big Buddy has an ODS low-oxygen pilot, a tip-over switch and ANSI Z21.103 certification, the standard for unvented camp heaters used indoors and outdoors. The manual lists fishing huts, and a bigger flame needs bigger vents.
The manual asks for 18 sq in of vent at the ceiling and again at floor level, about 4.25 by 4.25 in each. That is twice what the Portable Buddy needs, and it means two cut openings rather than a door zipper cracked a little.
Minnesota DNR wants a high and a low vent in every propane-heated shelter, a tested CO detector, and vents kept clear because snow can block them overnight. It also advises against relying on low-oxygen shut-offs, since the ODS cannot detect carbon monoxide.
Minnesota’s Department of Public Safety warns that CO in an ice house can reach deadly levels in under 20 minutes. Never bring the 20 lb tank inside, and never sleep with the heater burning.
Keep fabric, coats and bags well clear of the burner face, with the Buddy manuals’ 30 in above and 24 in in front. Our guide to venting an ice shelter sizes the openings for each heater.
What owners report
Owners praise the heat above all. Plenty of reviews describe a large hub warmed comfortably on high, and the heater keeps working in the garage once the ice is gone.
The complaints follow from its size. At 17.1 lb per Mr. Heater, on a 19 by 12 in footprint, it is heavy and bulky to carry out by hand. Some Amazon-side listings say 13 lb, but we go with the maker’s figure.
Owners also note how fast it empties 1 lb cylinders on high, and some say an opened door puts the pilot out. The product page and the listing show a 3-year limited warranty, while Mr. Heater’s policy page says 1 year.
It sits in the $$ band at some retailers, but others list it high enough to cross into the $$$ band, over $180. Compare a few sellers before you buy.
Against the Portable Buddy and the Hunting Buddy
The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy tops out at 9,000 BTU and 225 sq ft, weighs about 10.6 lb and needs half the vent area. For a two- or three-person hub it does the job on less fuel.
Our Portable Buddy or Big Buddy guide compares the two round by round, from shelter size to cylinders and venting.
The Hunting Buddy is the middle step at 6,000 or 12,000 BTU and 300 sq ft. It suits anglers who find the Portable Buddy short of heat but have no use for 18,000 BTU.
Mr. Heater makes all five of our picks, and no ice brand offers a portable rival at this output; Clam’s CH-10000vh stops at 10,000 BTU. See the Big Buddy card on our homepage or the full ice fishing heater comparison.
For the big hub or the shack
If you fish from a large hub or a semi-permanent shack and run a 20 lb tank anyway, the Big Buddy gives you more heat than anything else here. Cut two proper vents, hang a CO alarm and keep the tank outside.