Mr. Heater Buddy FLEX, a heater with a storage bay

The Buddy FLEX is Mr. Heater’s modular take on the shelter heater, with a variable burner, a storage bay and an optional cooker. We did not run one on the ice, so this review weighs the manual and Mr. Heater’s product page against what owners report.

Mr. Heater Buddy FLEX MH11BFLEX propane radiant heater with a ceramic burner and an accessory compartment Heat and storage

Price band $$$100 to $180 · Check the seller and return terms on the listing

Our verdict

The FLEX is a solid mid-size heater for a two- or three-person hub, with more heat than the Portable Buddy and a variable knob instead of two fixed steps. The storage bay and the FLEX Cooker are its reason to exist, and you pay for them in bulk. A 1 lb cylinder lasts only a few hours, so plan on a 20 lb tank outside the shelter. Long-term reports from the ice are still thin, which is why it is not our top pick.

Strengths

  • 8,000 to 11,000 BTU on a variable knob, rated for 275 sq ft
  • Built-in storage compartment for small accessories
  • Takes the Buddy FLEX Cooker and other FLEX accessories
  • ODS and tip-over switch, indoor-safe per Mr. Heater
  • 3-year limited warranty on the product page

Weaknesses

  • Only 1.5 to 3.5 hours per 1 lb cylinder
  • Heavier and bulkier than the Portable Buddy
  • Pulse ignition depends on a AAA battery
  • Few long-term reports from ice anglers
  • The 8,000 BTU low is too warm for a small flip-over

Buy it if

you share a mid-size hub, want more heat than a Portable Buddy gives and like the idea of a storage bay and a cooker that fits the heater.

Skip it if

you walk out to a small flip-over and want the lightest heater you can carry, or you plan to run all day on 1 lb cylinders.

Specs: Mr. Heater Buddy FLEX MH11BFLEX

TypePortable radiant propane heater with an accessory compartment
Heat output8,000 to 11,000 BTU/hr, variable
Rated heating areaUp to 275 sq ft per Mr. Heater
FuelOne 1 lb cylinder, or a 20 lb tank kept outside on a Buddy hose
Run time per 1 lb cylinder1.5 to 3.5 hours per the manual; 20 lb tank 36 to 72 hours
IgnitionBattery pulse ignition, 1 × AAA included
SafetyLow-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch; the manual lists fishing huts
Clearances30 in above, 24 in in front, 24 in at the sides
Fresh-air vent needed11 sq in at the ceiling and at floor level per the manual
Lowest working temperature0 °F in the manual’s spec table
ExtrasStorage compartment; takes the Buddy FLEX Cooker and other FLEX accessories
WeightAbout 11 lb
Not sold forMassachusetts and Canada
Warranty3-year limited on the product page

Data from the manufacturer’s manual and product page and from US retailers. Price band $$: $100 to $180. Only the price Amazon shows at checkout counts.

11,000 BTU for a two- or three-person hub

Mr. Heater rates the FLEX at 8,000 to 11,000 BTU per hour on a variable knob and says it heats up to 275 sq ft. That puts it between the 225 sq ft Portable Buddy and the 300 sq ft Hunting Buddy in our lineup.

A typical hub for two or three anglers has far less floor than 275 sq ft, so on paper the FLEX has heat to spare. Ice shelters are thin-walled and leaky, though, and a windy day eats rated area fast.

The low end matters as much as the top. At 8,000 BTU the FLEX cannot turn down as far as the Portable Buddy’s 4,000 BTU setting, so a small shelter on a mild day can get too warm and push you to open the door.

Radiant heat warms what it faces rather than the air around it, so aim the burner at your legs and the hole, not at a wall. Warm air still drifts to the roof, which is why a hub can feel hot at head height and cold at your boots.

Side view: warm air from a heater rises to the shelter roof while the floor stays cold, and a radiant heater warms a seated angler it faces
Warm air pools under the roof and leaves your boots on cold ice. A radiant heater set low and aimed at your legs puts the heat where you sit.

Run time, 1.5 to 3.5 hours a cylinder

The manual gives 1.5 to 3.5 hours on one 1 lb cylinder, high to low, and the product page says 2 hours at max and 3.5 at min. The arithmetic backs the short end, since the small cylinder carries only about 22,100 BTU in all.

At 11,000 BTU an hour that is about two hours, and at 8,000 it is under three. A full day on 1 lb cylinders means a bag of spares, kept outside the shelter and out of the sun, swapped with the heater off.

The better answer is a 20 lb tank on a Buddy hose, which the manual rates at 36 to 72 hours. The 10 ft F273704 works with no filter, whereas the F273701 or F273702 needs an F273699 filter, swapped out every year.

The tank always stays outside the shelter. Our 20 lb tank walkthrough goes through the hose and filter in order, and explains why a 1 lb DOT-39 cylinder is never to be refilled.

Bar chart of hours of heat from one pound of propane for the five heaters, from the high to the low setting
Hours per 1 lb cylinder from the manuals: the solid bar is the high setting, the pale bar how far low stretches it. Below 20 °F, small cylinders deliver less.

Rated down to 0 °F, with a cylinder that fades sooner

The FLEX manual’s spec table lists 0 °F as the lowest working temperature. Below that, Mr. Heater makes no promise that the heater will keep running, so on a subzero morning have a backup plan.

Like every Buddy manual, it also warns that run time drops sharply when you run the heater continuously below 20 °F. Propane vapor pressure falls with temperature, and a hard-working 1 lb cylinder chills itself until it frosts and the flame sags.

With far more liquid inside, a 20 lb tank holds its pressure better, which is why the manual recommends one in the cold. Our guide on why a 1 lb cylinder fades in deep cold explains the physics behind the frost ring.

Pulse ignition on a AAA battery

Where the Portable Buddy lights with a piezo click, the FLEX uses battery pulse ignition powered by one AAA cell, which comes in the box. A pulse igniter keeps sparking while you hold the control, which helps with a stubborn pilot.

Cold is hard on batteries, so keep a spare AAA in an inside pocket rather than in the tackle box. If the igniter goes quiet on the ice, a weak battery is the first thing to check.

Output is a variable knob between 8,000 and 11,000 BTU rather than fixed steps. Owners like being able to dial it, though you still adjust it by hand as the sun comes out or the wind picks up.

ODS, tip-over switch and 11 sq in of venting

The FLEX has a low-oxygen shut-off (ODS) and a tip-over switch, and Mr. Heater calls it indoor-safe everywhere except Massachusetts and Canada. Those are the two features we expect on any heater that goes inside a closed shelter.

An ODS reacts to oxygen loss and is blind to carbon monoxide, so the Minnesota DNR says not to depend on one. Hang a battery CO alarm, test it before every trip and treat the ODS as a backup.

The manual asks for 11 sq in of fresh-air vent, for example a 5.5 by 2 in opening, at the ceiling and at floor level. Keep snow off both, and keep the heater well clear of fabric walls, bags and clothes.

Burning propane also puts water vapor into the air, and in a closed hub it ends up as frost on the roof and drips on your gear. The same vents help here, and our guide to frost and dripping shelter walls covers the rest.

Cook only with the FLEX Cooker (MH8CFLEX), the accessory made for this heater, and never set a pan or a can on the burner face. Never sleep in a shelter with the heater running.

Owners like the bay, not the bulk

Owner reports for the FLEX are thinner than for the Portable Buddy, and few cover long winters on the ice. Most shanty owners still judge it against the Portable Buddy, the heater they already know.

The storage compartment and the cooker attachment get the most praise, mainly from anglers who want hot food without packing a second stove. The variable output earns kind words too.

The complaints are the ones you would guess. The FLEX is heavier and bulkier than the Portable Buddy, and a 1 lb cylinder lasts only a few hours, so many owners end up on a 20 lb tank anyway.

How it stacks up against two siblings

The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy is lighter and simpler, and its 4,000 BTU low setting stretches a cylinder much further. That is why it is our top pick, and our Portable Buddy vs Buddy FLEX comparison goes through them round by round.

The Hunting Buddy offers 6,000 or 12,000 BTU and two small side compartments, but no cooker. For a large hub the Big Buddy’s 18,000 BTU is the step up, and Clam’s CH-10000vh, at 5,500 to 10,000 BTU, is the main rival from outside Mr. Heater.

Mr. Heater rates the FLEX for the same shelters and fuel setups as its siblings, so the choice comes down to features and weight. See the FLEX on our shortlist or the full table of the best ice fishing heaters we compared.

For the angler who wants heat and a hot lunch

If you share a mid-size hub and want one heater that also stores small gear and takes the FLEX Cooker, the FLEX does both jobs. Run it from a 20 lb tank outside, vent high and low, and keep a CO alarm on the wall.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Mr. Heater Buddy FLEX

How big a shelter can the Buddy FLEX heat?

Mr. Heater rates it for up to 275 sq ft at 8,000 to 11,000 BTU. That is plenty for a two- or three-person hub, though wind and thin walls cut what any heater can do.

What run time does the Buddy FLEX get from a 1 lb cylinder?

Between 1.5 hours on high and 3.5 on low, per the manual. Hook up an outdoor 20 lb tank with a Buddy hose and that grows to 36 to 72 hours.

Can I cook on the Mr. Heater Buddy FLEX?

Only with the Buddy FLEX Cooker accessory (MH8CFLEX), which is made for it. Never put a pan or a can on the heater face.

Does the Buddy FLEX need batteries?

One AAA battery powers the pulse ignition, and one comes in the box. Carry a spare in a warm pocket, since cold weakens batteries.

How much venting does the FLEX need in an ice shelter?

The manual asks for 11 sq in of fresh-air opening, for example 5.5 by 2 in, at the ceiling and at floor level. Keep both clear of snow and run a battery CO alarm as well.