Buddy FLEX or Hunting Buddy heater for a mid-size shelter

These two sit between the Portable Buddy and the Big Buddy, with matching run times and the same hose options. The Hunting Buddy spans a wider heat range, while the FLEX brings a storage bay, a cooker accessory and better-documented specs.

A close call, decided by heat range or by extras

Take the Hunting Buddy if you want the widest range in a mid-size heater. It idles at 6,000 BTU through slow hours and climbs to 12,000 when the wind finds the seams of a three-person hub.

Take the Buddy FLEX if you value a storage bay, a cooker accessory and a confirmed 3-year warranty over a little more heat. Its paper trail is cleaner, which counts for a heater you will trust in a closed shelter.

Both appear on our ice fishing heater comparison, as pick 4 and pick 5. If neither fits, the FLEX also faces the Portable Buddy, and the Hunting Buddy meets the Big Buddy.

Buddy FLEX and Hunting Buddy side by side

We drew these specs from Mr. Heater manuals, its product pages and a few store listings. Where a Hunting Buddy detail such as the SKU, warranty or price stayed unconfirmed, the table flags it.

FeatureMr. Heater Buddy FLEX MH11BFLEXMr. Heater Hunting Buddy MH12HB
Heat outputStepless, 8,000 to 11,000 BTU/hrLow 6,000 or high 12,000 BTU/hr
Rated heating area275 sq ft maximum300 sq ft maximum
Fuel and cylindersDisposable 1 lb cylinder, or bulk 20 lb tank by hose from outdoorsSame two routes
Run time per 1 lbManual lists 1.5 to 3.5 hoursManual lists the same 1.5 to 3.5
IgnitionPulse ignition, one AAA battery (included)Pulse ignition, one AA battery
SafetyLow-oxygen and tip-over shut-offs, called indoor-safeLow-oxygen and tip-over shut-offs, CSA 4.98
Fresh-air vent needed11 sq in, split roof and floor12 sq in per the spec page, 9 per troubleshooting
WeightAbout 11 lbRoughly 16 lb in store listings, which may include packaging
Price band$$Likely $$ (estimate)
Warranty3 years limited, product pageUnconfirmed

Heat range and rated area

Mr. Heater rates the Hunting Buddy for up to 300 sq ft at 12,000 BTU and the FLEX for 275 sq ft at 11,000. That top-end gap is small, about 9 percent, and you would struggle to feel it in a hub.

The low end is where they part. The Hunting Buddy drops to 6,000 BTU, while the FLEX stops at 8,000, so the Hunting Buddy idles more gently once the shelter is warm. The FLEX answers with a stepless dial between its two limits.

Neither is a flip-over heater for one angler, since both start above the Portable Buddy’s low setting. Our guide to BTUs and shelter size helps you check that a mid-size heater fits your hub.

Round goes to the Hunting Buddy, for the wider range.

Fuel, run time and hoses

On paper the two burn alike. Their manuals agree on 1.5 to 3.5 hours from a small cylinder and 36 to 72 from a 20 lb tank, and Hunting Buddy owners grumble most about how fast the high setting empties a cylinder.

Bar chart of hours of heat from one pound of propane for the five heaters, from the high to the low setting
Hours per 1 lb cylinder from the manuals: the solid bar is the high setting, the pale bar how far low stretches it. Below 20 °F, small cylinders deliver less.

Each accepts the same family of Buddy hoses running in from a bulk tank in the snow, and the 10 ft F273704 needs no filter. That tank stays outdoors, and cylinders go on and come off outdoors too.

At this output, a day on 1 lb cylinders means a heavy bag of spares. Our guide to propane in the cold explains why those cylinders fade even faster on a subzero morning.

Round goes to neither, a draw.

Cold weather and ignition

Both lift Mr. Heater’s warning that run times drop sharply below 20 °F, along with the advice to use a 20 lb tank. The FLEX manual adds a lowest working temperature of 0 °F, a figure we did not find for the Hunting Buddy.

Both use battery pulse ignition, AAA in the FLEX and AA in the Hunting Buddy. Cold drains small cells, so carry a spare of the right size in an inner pocket rather than in the sled.

The Hunting Buddy manual warns that the heater may shut off above 7,000 ft. We did not find that line in the FLEX extract, though the caution applies across the Buddy line.

Round goes to the Buddy FLEX, for its documented 0 °F rating.

Safety and venting

Neither lacks the core hardware, since both cut out on low oxygen or a fall. Both manuals list fishing huts as approved spaces, and the Hunting Buddy’s also cites CSA 4.98, while the FLEX is sold as indoor-safe except in Massachusetts and Canada.

For air, the FLEX wants 11 sq in shared between a high and a low opening. The Hunting Buddy’s manual contradicts itself, 12 sq in among the specs and 9 under troubleshooting, so plan on the larger figure.

  • One vent near the roof and one near the floor, kept clear of snow
  • A battery CO alarm, because the ODS senses oxygen, not carbon monoxide
  • The heater well away from fabric walls, bags and clothes
  • No sleeping in the shelter with the heater burning

Our nine safety rules for a heated shelter cover the rest, from leak checks to storing cylinders outside overnight.

Round goes to neither, the safety hardware matches.

Build, weight and extras

The FLEX hides a storage cubby and works with add-ons such as the MH8CFLEX cooker. Food goes on that cooker only, never on the glowing face. Next to a Portable Buddy, owners describe the FLEX as the bulkier package.

The Hunting Buddy was built for blinds, with a camo finish, a fold-down handle and two small side compartments. Owners call it quiet with steady heat. Retailers list it at about 16 lb, which may be a shipping weight, against about 11 lb for the FLEX.

Shop with care, because an older Hunting Buddy listing titled with a fan is a different variant. Look for the MH12HB in the title.

Round goes to the Buddy FLEX, for the cooker and a lighter listed weight.

Price band and warranty

The FLEX sits in the $$ band, $100 to $180, with a 3-year limited warranty on its product page. We estimate the Hunting Buddy in the same band but could not confirm its price or its warranty, so read the listing closely.

Mr. Heater dominates this middle ground. If you want a different maker, the Clam CH-10000vh covers 5,500 to 10,000 BTU and 250 sq ft, though we did not confirm its availability. Our brand comparison weighs the makers.

Round goes to the Buddy FLEX, on confirmed cover.

The Hunting Buddy’s record has gaps. Its SKU, warranty and price band are unconfirmed, and its manual gives two different vent figures, so you buy it partly on the strength of the Buddy family.

The FLEX has gaps too. Few owners have reported on it after many winters on the ice, and its minimum output of 8,000 BTU is a lot for a small shelter.

Two middle steps, one shelter question

For a three-person hub with long, slow hours, the Hunting Buddy’s 6,000 to 12,000 BTU range fits well. Choose the Buddy FLEX if you prize the storage bay and cooker, and want a warranty you can confirm before you pay.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Buddy FLEX and the Hunting Buddy

Which is warmer, the Buddy FLEX or the Hunting Buddy?

The Hunting Buddy, slightly. It reaches 12,000 BTU and is rated for up to 300 sq ft, against 11,000 BTU and 275 sq ft for the FLEX. It also turns down further, to 6,000 BTU against 8,000.

Do they use the same propane hose?

Yes. Either takes a 1 lb cylinder, or a Buddy hose run in from a 20 lb tank sitting outdoors. No filter is needed on the 10 ft F273704, whereas the F273701 and F273702 each call for an F273699 inline filter.

How big a vent does the Hunting Buddy need?

Its manual gives 12 sq in on the spec page and 9 sq in in the troubleshooting section. Plan on 12 sq in, split between an opening near the roof and one near the floor, and carry a CO alarm.

Does either heater need batteries?

Only for lighting. The Buddy FLEX uses one AAA battery, included, and the Hunting Buddy uses one AA battery. Keep a spare in a warm pocket, because cold weakens small cells.

Is the Hunting Buddy only for deer blinds?

No. It was designed with hunters in mind, but its manual names fishing huts among approved enclosures and it carries an ODS and a tip-over switch. Owners describe quiet, steady heat in shanties as well as blinds.