When the heater pilot won’t stay lit, seven fixes

A pilot that lights and then dies is the most common complaint about Buddy heaters after a few winters. Most causes are simple and free to fix, and one of them is the heater warning you that the air is getting thin.

How the pilot keeps itself lit

A Buddy heater lights in two steps. You press and hold the control to send gas to the pilot, spark it, and keep holding while the small flame heats a sensor called a thermocouple.

Once the thermocouple is hot, it holds the gas valve open by itself. If the flame wavers, shrinks or moves off the sensor, the valve closes and the pilot goes out.

On Buddy heaters the pilot is also the ODS, the low-oxygen shut-off. When oxygen drops, the pilot flame lifts off the sensor and the heater shuts down, which is the safety system doing its job.

If the heater keeps shutting off in a closed shelter, assume low oxygen until you prove otherwise. Open the vents, get everyone into fresh air if anyone has a headache or feels dizzy, and check your CO alarm before you relight.

The seven fixes run from the most common and least work to the last resort. Work through them in order and stop at the first one that cures it.

1. Hold the control longer

The thermocouple needs time to heat up. Let go too soon and the valve closes, so hold the control in for longer than feels necessary after the pilot lights, then release it slowly.

The Little Buddy manual names this first in its troubleshooting section, telling you to hold the button long enough. Owners of every Buddy model say the same, especially on a cold heater.

If you get no spark at all, check the igniter. The Portable Buddy and Big Buddy use a piezo spark, while the Buddy FLEX and the Hunting Buddy use a battery pulse igniter, so a dead AAA or AA cell is the first suspect.

2. Get it out of the draft

A pilot flame is tiny, and wind or an opening door can blow it out or push it off the sensor. Owners report this on every Buddy model, and the manual itself mentions nuisance shut-offs outdoors.

Turn the heater so its back faces the door, and keep it away from the low vent where cold air comes in. Don’t block or shrink the vents to stop the draft, though, because the heater needs that air.

3. Warm up or swap the cylinder

In deep cold a 1 lb cylinder can’t vaporize propane fast enough, so pressure sags and the pilot starves. Frost on the cylinder is the sign, and Mr. Heater’s advice is to wipe it off or move to a larger tank outside.

Keep spare cylinders somewhere less cold than the open ice, such as a cooler in the truck, and never beside the heater. The guide to propane in the cold explains why, and the 20 lb tank setup is the lasting fix.

4. Give it fresh air

If the pilot lights well, runs for a while and then dies, low oxygen is a likely cause. The ODS is built to shut the heater off as oxygen falls, so this often means the vents are too small or snowed over.

Clear the vents and air the shelter out for a few minutes before you relight. The manuals size the vent per model, 9 sq in on the Portable Buddy and 18 sq in on the Big Buddy, and the ventilation guide shows where to put them.

The ODS senses oxygen, not carbon monoxide, so this fix never replaces an alarm. The carbon monoxide guide covers the symptoms to watch for in everyone in the shelter.

Altitude has the same effect. Above 7,000 ft the Buddy manuals say the heater may burn dimmer and shut off, and they advise fresh air, a 5-minute wait and a relight, adding that it may not relight.

5. Level it and reset the tip-over switch

Every Buddy has a tip-over switch that cuts the gas if the heater leans too far. On uneven ice, a sloping sled floor or a bucket lid, it can trip at an angle you hardly notice.

Set the heater on a flat, firm surface and turn the control fully off before relighting. Owners who cure a stubborn pilot often do it by working the tip-over and off switches back to their normal positions.

6. Check the hose and filter

A pilot that fails mostly on the remote tank points at the fuel line. Hoses other than the F273704 need the F273699 filter, which Mr. Heater calls an oil trap and says to replace every year.

Oily residue that slips past a missing or tired filter can foul the small pilot passages. Fit a fresh filter, make sure the tank valve is open all the way, and leak-check every joint with soapy water.

7. Clean the pilot, or replace the ODS assembly

If nothing so far has worked, dirt in the pilot is the usual culprit on older heaters. With the heater cold and the fuel disconnected, owners blow out the pilot tube, and that alone brings many heaters back.

When a cleaned pilot still won’t hold, the fix is to replace the ODS pilot assembly. Contact Mr. Heater about the part and your warranty, or have a qualified gas service technician fit it if you aren’t comfortable working on gas parts.

Never bypass the ODS or the tip-over switch to keep a heater running. A heater with a defeated safety shut-off has no place in a closed shelter.

When a new heater makes more sense

Mr. Heater’s product pages show a 3-year limited warranty on the Buddy line, though its policy page says 1 year, so ask before you pay for parts. An old heater with a failing pilot and no warranty may be due for retirement.

If you are weighing a replacement, our guide to which ice fishing heater to buy compares the five, and the comparison table lines up their safety features. Mr. Heater dominates the category, and the brand guide covers Clam and the other routes.

The Portable Buddy card on the home page explains why it is the heater we would replace an old one with.

If your old heater is past saving

The Portable Buddy is the heater most of these fixes were learned on, and its piezo spark needs no batteries. It gives 9,000 BTU from a small cylinder or from a 20 lb tank outside, with an ODS and a tip-over switch, though its pilot can still go out in a draft.

Questions and answers

More questions about a pilot that won’t stay lit

Why does my Buddy heater pilot go out when I let go of the knob?

Usually the thermocouple has not heated up yet. Hold the control in longer after the pilot lights, then release it slowly. If it still drops out, check for drafts and a cold or frosted cylinder.

Why does my heater shut off after running for a while?

Low oxygen is a common cause, since the ODS shuts the heater off as oxygen falls. Clear and enlarge the vents, air the shelter out, and check your CO alarm before relighting.

Can wind put out a Buddy heater pilot?

Yes. Owners report wind and door drafts blowing out the pilot, and the manual mentions nuisance shut-offs outdoors. Turn the heater away from the door, but never close the vents to stop a draft.

When should I replace the ODS pilot assembly?

When the heater is level, the fuel supply is good, the vents are clear and a cleaned pilot still won’t stay lit. Contact Mr. Heater about the part, or have a qualified gas technician fit it.

Can I bypass the ODS so the heater stays on?

No. The ODS and tip-over switch are what make a Buddy heater fit for a closed shelter. A heater with a defeated safety shut-off should never be used indoors.