Mr. Heater Portable Buddy, the shelter heater we would buy
The Portable Buddy is the heater we would hand a friend heading out to a two- or three-person hub. It is simple, quiet and documented in a manual that names fishing huts. We did not take one onto the ice, so this review weighs Mr. Heater’s figures against what owners report.
Our top pick
Our verdict
The Portable Buddy is the safest default for most ice anglers because it matches the size of a typical hub and needs nothing but propane. Its manual approves fishing huts, asks for a modest 9 sq in vent and spells out the clearances. On high a 1 lb cylinder lasts only a few hours, and the pilot gets touchy after a few winters. Run it off a 20 lb tank on cold days, vent the shelter and carry a CO alarm, and it is easy to live with.
Strengths
- 4,000 or 9,000 BTU, rated for up to 225 sq ft
- Piezo ignition, no batteries or fan to fail in the cold
- ODS and tip-over switch, manual approves fishing huts
- Runs a 20 lb tank outside the shelter on a Buddy hose
- Light enough to carry, about 10.6 lb
Weaknesses
- High setting drains a 1 lb cylinder in a few hours
- Pilot can quit after a few seasons or in a draft
- 1 lb cylinders frost and fade below 20 °F
- Radiant heat warms what it faces, not the whole shelter
- Warranty length differs between Mr. Heater pages
Buy it if
you fish from a one- to three-person hub or flip-over and want one indoor-rated heater with two settings, no batteries and the option of a 20 lb tank.
Skip it if
you heat a large hub or a shack with several anglers, or you will not cut vents and carry a CO alarm.
Specs: Mr. Heater Portable Buddy MH9BX
| Type | Portable radiant propane heater, ceramic burner |
|---|---|
| Heat output | 4,000 or 9,000 BTU/hr (low and high) |
| Rated heating area | Up to 225 sq ft per Mr. Heater |
| Fuel | One 1 lb propane cylinder, or a 20 lb tank kept outside the shelter on a Buddy hose |
| Run time per 1 lb cylinder | 3 to 6 hours per the manual (Mr. Heater’s page says up to 5.4) |
| Ignition | Piezo spark, no batteries |
| Safety | Low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch, CSA 4.98; the manual lists fishing huts among approved enclosures |
| Fresh-air vent needed | 9 sq in minimum per the manual (for example 3 × 3 in) |
| Clearances | 30 in above, 24 in in front, 6 in at the sides |
| Cold weather | Run time drops sharply below 20 °F on a 1 lb cylinder; the manual recommends a 20 lb tank |
| Altitude | May burn dimmer and shut off above 7,000 ft |
| Power | None, no fan |
| Weight | About 10.6 lb (retailer figures vary) |
| Not sold for | Massachusetts and Canada (separate outdoor-only version) |
| Warranty | 3-year limited on the product page (Mr. Heater’s policy page says 1 year) |
Data from the manufacturer’s manual and product page and from US retailers. Price band $$: $100 to $180. Only the price Amazon shows at checkout counts.
Heat output and shelter size, 4,000 or 9,000 BTU
Mr. Heater rates the Portable Buddy at 4,000 BTU on low and 9,000 BTU on high, and says it heats up to 225 sq ft. That covers most two- and three-person hubs, with spare heat for a one-angler flip-over.
The burner is a radiant ceramic face, so it warms what it points at before it warms the air. Aim it at your legs and the hole, not at a fabric wall, and the shelter feels warmer than the thermometer says.
Warm air still climbs to the roof, though, and on a windy day your boots stay colder than your hat. The low setting is enough for many mild afternoons, while high earns its keep when the wind finds every seam.
Fuel and run time on a 1 lb cylinder or a 20 lb tank
The heater takes one 1 lb propane cylinder that threads into the side. The manual gives 3 to 6 hours per cylinder from high to low, while Mr. Heater’s product page says up to 5.4 hours.
The physics favors the short end on high. Each 1 lb cylinder stores about 22,100 BTU worth of propane, so a 9,000 BTU flame drains it in about two and a half hours. Plan on 2.5 to 3 hours on high and the longer figures on low.
For a full day, most owners switch to a 20 lb tank that stays outside the shelter. Mr. Heater’s 10 ft Buddy hose (F273704) needs no filter, while the 5 ft and 12 ft hoses (F273701 and F273702) need the F273699 fuel filter, replaced every year.
On a 20 lb tank the manual quotes 48 to 110 hours of heat. Our guide to the 20 lb tank setup covers the hose, the filter and where the tank should sit.
Skip the refill adapters that some bundles include. PHMSA says DOT-39 cylinders, the familiar 1 lb green bottles, must never be refilled, and incidents with refilled ones have happened.
Cold-weather performance below 20 °F
Every Buddy manual warns that run times drop significantly when the heater runs continuously below 20 °F, and this one recommends a 20 lb tank in those conditions. The cause is vapor pressure, not a fault in the heater.
Propane boils at about −44 °F, but a small cylinder chills as it feeds the flame. The colder the liquid gets, the less vapor it delivers, so the cylinder frosts over and the flame sags until the heater rests.
A 20 lb tank holds far more liquid and keeps its pressure much longer, which is why owners who fish the coldest weeks nearly all move to one. Mr. Heater adds that above 7,000 ft the heater may burn dimmer and shut off.
Lighting and controls with no batteries
Ignition is a piezo spark on the control knob, so there are no batteries to die in the cold. You hold the knob on Pilot, click the igniter until the pilot catches, then turn to low or high once it stays lit.
There is no fan and nothing to plug in, which is why owners call it quiet. The flip side is that heat stays where the burner points, so careful aim matters more than the high setting.
The complaint owners raise most is a pilot that quits staying lit after a few seasons. The usual fix is blowing out the pilot tube and resetting the tip-over and off switches, and failing that, replacing the ODS pilot assembly.
Our guide for when the pilot won’t stay lit walks through seven fixes in order, from the cheap ones to the part swap.
Safety features and ventilation in a closed shelter
The Portable Buddy has a low-oxygen pilot (ODS) and a tip-over switch, and it carries CSA 4.98 certification for recreational and commercial use. Its manual names fishing huts and tents among the small enclosures it may be used in.
That approval comes with conditions. The manual asks for at least 9 sq in of open vent, about a 3 by 3 in hole, plus clearances of 30 in above, 24 in in front and 6 in at the sides.
Keep bags, coats and fabric walls out of that zone, and run no other fuel-burning appliance inside, as the manual says. Connect and disconnect cylinders outdoors, and store spares outside the shelter overnight.
The ODS senses oxygen, not carbon monoxide. Minnesota DNR tells anglers not to depend on low-oxygen shut-offs, and it asks for one high vent and one low vent in every propane-heated shelter, plus a CO detector you test regularly.
So hang a battery CO alarm, brush snow off the vents, and never sleep with the heater running. Our shelter ventilation guide shows how to size and place the openings.
What owners report after a few winters
Plenty of owner reviews exist, and the praise is consistent. Anglers describe it as the default shanty heater because it runs quietly, needs no electricity and carries easily at about 10.6 lb.
The complaints are just as consistent. Besides the pilot that tires with age, owners say wind or an open door can blow the pilot out, and 1 lb cylinders frost and fade on the coldest days.
Owners also stress a separate CO alarm, because the heater’s sensor watches oxygen only. Mr. Heater shows a 3-year limited warranty on the product page, but its general policy page says 1 year, so keep the receipt.
The heater is not sold for Massachusetts or Canada. The version made for those markets is labeled not indoor-safe, so check that a listing shows the standard US model.
Against the Big Buddy, the Little Buddy and the rest
The Mr. Heater Big Buddy doubles the top output to 18,000 BTU and the rated area to 450 sq ft. It weighs about 17.1 lb and needs two 1 lb cylinders for high, so it suits big hubs and shacks better than a walk-out.
Our Portable Buddy or Big Buddy comparison weighs the two side by side. For most two- or three-person hubs, the smaller heater does the job on less fuel.
The Little Buddy costs less and weighs about half as much, but its single 3,800 BTU setting and lack of a hose port tie it to small flip-overs. The Buddy FLEX and Hunting Buddy sit between this heater and the Big Buddy in output.
Mr. Heater dominates this category. The main ice-brand rival at a similar size is the Clam CH-10000vh, rated 5,500 to 10,000 BTU, though we could not confirm it in stock.
All five picks sit side by side on the Portable Buddy’s homepage card and in our comparison of the best ice fishing heaters, with the specs in one table.
The heater we would put in our own hub
For a two- or three-person shelter, the Portable Buddy gives you enough heat, no batteries to fail and a long record of owner fixes. Vent the shelter high and low, hang a CO alarm and move to a 20 lb tank when the cold sets in.