Carbon monoxide in an ice shack, and why your heater needs an alarm
Carbon monoxide has no color and no smell, and a small closed shelter is about the worst place to meet it. This guide covers where it comes from, why your heater’s low-oxygen shut-off won’t catch it, and why a battery alarm belongs in every shelter you heat.
Where the carbon monoxide comes from
Propane that burns cleanly leaves carbon dioxide and water vapor. When the flame is short of oxygen or burns badly, part of the carbon leaves as carbon monoxide (CO) instead, a gas you can’t see or smell.
A closed shelter makes it worse with time. The heater keeps using oxygen, the air carries more exhaust, and combustion gets poorer unless fresh air comes in to replace what the flame has used.
A catalytic heater burns without a visible flame, but that does not make it fume-free. It still uses oxygen and needs the vent area its manual asks for, and our guide to radiant or catalytic heaters compares the two types.
Some catalytic models lack a low-oxygen sensor and rely on a thermocouple valve alone. The Portable Buddy has an ODS, but with either type the open vents and a CO alarm do the real protecting.
How fast it builds and what it does to you
Minnesota’s Department of Public Safety says CO in an ice house can climb to deadly levels in less than 20 minutes. That is shorter than the wait between flags on a slow afternoon.
CO latches onto the hemoglobin in your blood about 200 times more readily than oxygen does. It crowds the oxygen out, starving your brain and heart, and the harm keeps building while you sit still on a bucket.
Symptoms to watch for
Minnesota DNR lists the warning signs below. They feel a lot like a long cold day, which is exactly why people shrug them off.
- Headache
- Nausea
- Fatigue or drowsiness
- Dizziness
- Confusion
If anyone in the shelter has them, shut the heater off and get everyone out into fresh air. Call 911 if someone is confused or hard to wake, and don’t go back in until the shelter has aired out and you know the cause.
Why the ODS won’t warn you
Every Buddy heater has a low-oxygen pilot, the ODS, that shuts off the gas when oxygen falls. It measures oxygen, not CO, and owners in forum threads keep repeating that it is no reason to skip a separate alarm.
Minnesota DNR advises not to rely on low-oxygen shut-offs. CO can climb to a harmful level before oxygen drops far enough to trip the pilot, especially when the heater is burning poorly.
A heater that keeps shutting itself off is telling you something. Before you work through our fixes for a pilot that won’t stay lit, open the vents and step outside, because low oxygen is one of the things that drops the pilot.
The alarm that belongs in every shelter
Minnesota DNR says every ice shelter should have a CO detector, tested regularly, and its carbon monoxide page explains why. The CDC advises an alarm that is battery-powered or has battery backup, the only kind that works on the ice.
- Choose a battery model, ideally one with a display that shows the reading
- Mount it where you will hear and see it, not inside a bag or behind the heater
- Test it before each trip and carry spare batteries
- Read its operating temperature range, since household alarms are built for heated rooms
- Replace it by the date printed on it, because CO sensors wear out
A CO alarm is the one piece of kit that measures the danger itself. Vents and the ODS lower the odds, and the alarm tells you when they were not enough.
Vents and the alarm work as a pair
The CDC warns against using gas heaters inside a tent or enclosed shelter, and found that cracking flaps or windows alone may not stop CO from building up. Shelter heaters like the Buddy line are certified for recreational enclosures, but only with the vent area their manuals demand.
Size your openings with our guide to venting a shelter in square inches, one high and one low, and keep them clear of snow. Then run the alarm anyway.
Other states say much the same. Wisconsin’s health department warns against propane heaters in enclosed areas, ice fishing shanties included, and recommends battery CO detectors, while Michigan’s ice-fishing CO flyer tells anglers to read the heater instructions for shanty use.
Habits that keep CO down
- Use only a heater rated for indoor use, never a tank-top heater such as the Mr. Heater MH15T, which is labeled for outdoor use only
- Run one fuel-burning appliance in the shelter, as every Buddy manual asks
- Never sleep in a shelter with the heater running
- Have a heater that burns unevenly or smells odd looked at before the next trip
- If the alarm sounds, shut the heater off, get out and don’t relight it until you know why
Our nine rules for a heated shelter gather these habits in one place. For heaters with the safety features that matter, see the safest ice fishing heaters in our comparison, starting with the top pick and the tips before you buy.
No heater on this site is safe in a sealed shelter. The ODS, the tip-over switch and the indoor rating all assume open vents, and only an alarm tells you when the air has turned.
For a shelter you heat often
Mr. Heater gives the Portable Buddy a low-oxygen pilot and a tip-over switch, it is CSA 4.98 certified, and its manual names fishing huts as an approved enclosure. None of that replaces a battery CO alarm and open vents, so buy the alarm along with it.