Portable Buddy or Little Buddy, two small heaters
Both are compact Mr. Heater radiant units that burn a 1 lb propane cylinder and guard you with an ODS and a tip-over switch. The Portable Buddy adds a second heat setting and a hose port, while the Little Buddy is lighter and sits a band lower.
The Portable Buddy for most anglers, the Little Buddy for a solo flip-over
Anglers who share a hub with one or two friends, or who stay out past dark in deep cold, are better off with the Portable Buddy. It puts out more than twice the heat on high and can switch to a 20 lb tank when small cylinders start to fade.
The Little Buddy makes sense when you fish alone or with one friend in a small flip-over, mostly on milder days. It weighs about 5 lb less and needs the smallest vent of any Buddy heater.
Both sit on our ice fishing heater shortlist, the Portable Buddy as our top pick and the Little Buddy as the budget pick. The Portable Buddy also meets the Buddy FLEX and the Big Buddy.
Portable Buddy and Little Buddy side by side
Our numbers are taken from Mr. Heater’s own manuals and product pages, and the weights from retailer listings. When two sources give different values, both appear in the table.
| Feature | Mr. Heater Portable Buddy MH9BX | Mr. Heater Little Buddy MH4B |
|---|---|---|
| Heat output | Low 4,000, high 9,000 BTU/hr | 3,800 BTU/hr, one setting |
| Rated heating area | Up to 225 sq ft | 95 sq ft (Mr. Heater’s copy says up to 100) |
| Fuel and cylinders | 1 lb cylinder on top, or a hose to a 20 lb tank left outdoors | One 1 lb cylinder only, no hose option |
| Run time per 1 lb | Manual says 3 to 6 hours, product page up to 5.4 | Manual says about 5 hours, product page 5.6 |
| Ignition | Piezo spark, no batteries | Piezo, hold the button 30 to 60 seconds |
| Safety | Low-oxygen sensor, tip-over cut-off, CSA 4.98 listed | Same pair of shut-offs, also CSA 4.98 |
| Fresh-air vent needed | 9 sq in minimum | 4 sq in minimum |
| Weight | About 10.6 lb | About 5.9 lb without cylinder (up to 8 lb on some listings) |
| Price band | $$, sometimes under $100 on sale | $ (under $100) |
| Warranty | Product page lists 3 years limited, the policy page 1 year | We could not confirm it |
Heat output, 9,000 against 3,800 BTU
On high, the Portable Buddy burns 9,000 BTU an hour, and Mr. Heater rates it for up to 225 sq ft. The Little Buddy has a single 3,800 BTU setting, rated at 95 sq ft in the spec field and up to 100 in the page copy.
Owners report that the Little Buddy keeps one or two anglers comfortable in a small shanty on a mild day. They also say it falls behind in hubs over about 100 sq ft, and whenever the wind picks up or the mercury drops hard.
The Portable Buddy’s 4,000 BTU low setting earns its keep too. Heat the hub hard while you drill and rig, then turn it down to stretch the cylinder. Our BTU sizing guide shows how to match output to your shelter.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy, for more heat and a second setting.
Fuel, run time and the hose port
On a single 1 lb cylinder the Little Buddy is listed at about 5 hours, and the Portable Buddy at anywhere from 3 to 6. Since each small cylinder carries something like 22,100 BTU, a Portable Buddy left on high drains one in about two and a half hours.
The bigger split is the hose. Only the Portable Buddy can draw on a 20 lb tank parked outdoors, good for 48 to 110 hours per the manual, and the 10 ft Buddy hose (F273704) needs no fuel filter.
The Little Buddy takes 1 lb cylinders and nothing else, so you pack spares. Keep them outside the shelter and out of the sun, and skip refill adapters, since DOT-39 cylinders must never be refilled. Our 20 lb tank guide covers the hose and filter.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy, thanks to the hose port.
Cold-weather performance below 20 °F
Run either nonstop under 20 °F and its manual expects much shorter run times, and the Portable Buddy manual points you to a 20 lb tank instead. Propane boils at about −44 °F, yet its pressure sags well before that, and a small cylinder chills itself as it feeds the burner.
Mr. Heater suggests wiping the frost off a struggling cylinder or moving to a larger remote tank. Only the Portable Buddy can take the second route, so on a subzero morning the Little Buddy is stuck with a fading flame.
Our guide to 1 lb cylinders in deep cold explains vapor pressure and the habits that help, such as keeping spare cylinders warm until you need them.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy.
Safety, venting and the CO alarm
On paper the two match, each with an oxygen depletion sensor (ODS), a tip-over cut-off, CSA 4.98 certification and fishing huts listed in the manual. That sensor reads oxygen levels only, never CO, which is why the Minnesota DNR tells anglers not to lean on it.
The vent rules differ. The Little Buddy manual asks for at least 4 sq in of fresh-air opening and the Portable Buddy for 9 sq in, and the DNR wants one vent near the top of a propane-heated shelter and one near the bottom.
- A battery CO alarm in the shelter, tested before each trip
- Clearance from walls and gear (30 in above and 24 in in front for the Portable Buddy)
- No sleeping with either heater lit
- Snow brushed off the vents through the day
The smaller heater needs less air, but it still makes CO, and a cold, sealed shelter is where trouble starts. Our venting guide turns those square inches into openings you can cut or unzip.
Round goes to neither, a draw on safety hardware.
Build, weight and lighting
The Little Buddy stands on its own cylinder, about 12 in tall, and weighs around 5.9 lb before fuel. Owners like how it tucks into a flip-over sled. The Portable Buddy is closer to 10.6 lb, still light enough to carry in one hand.
Both light with a piezo spark and need no batteries. Owners call the Little Buddy’s button fiddly because you hold it 30 to 60 seconds, while the Portable Buddy’s known weak spot is a pilot that stops staying lit after a few seasons.
Durability reports differ as well. Some Little Buddy owners say theirs lasted a season or two, and many say the Portable Buddy is the better long-term value. Our pilot troubleshooting guide covers the usual Buddy fixes.
Round goes to the Little Buddy, on weight and size.
Price band and value over several winters
You will pay under $100 for the Little Buddy, which puts it in our $ band. The Portable Buddy belongs to the $$ band, though other sellers sometimes list it under $100, so the gap can shrink to almost nothing.
On paper the warranty favors the Portable Buddy, with 3 years limited on its product page, while Mr. Heater’s policy page says 1 year. We could not confirm the Little Buddy’s cover, so read the listing before you order.
Round goes to the Portable Buddy, on value over the long run.
The Little Buddy cannot grow with you. With one setting and no hose, it stays a small-shelter heater, so moving up to a hub later means buying a second heater.
The Portable Buddy has its own catch. Door drafts and wind can blow out the pilot, and after a few seasons many units need the pilot tube cleaned or the ODS assembly replaced.
Two small heaters, two kinds of angler
For most anglers the Portable Buddy is the one to buy, because it covers a bigger shelter and moves to a 20 lb tank when the cold bites. Choose the Little Buddy if you fish alone in a small flip-over and want the lightest, cheapest Buddy.