Portable Buddy vs Buddy FLEX heater, simple or modular

The Portable Buddy and the Buddy FLEX each take either a small 1 lb cylinder or a hose-fed 20 lb tank, and both carry an ODS and a tip-over switch. The FLEX adds heat, a dial, a storage bay and a cooker accessory, and it pays for them in run time.

Simplicity wins for most shelters, the FLEX suits a bigger hub

Pick the Portable Buddy if you want the plain, proven heater that lights without batteries and stretches a 1 lb cylinder furthest. It covers a two- or three-person hub, and its low setting lets you idle the heat through a long wait.

Pick the Buddy FLEX if your hub is on the large side, you plan to run a 20 lb tank anyway, and you like the idea of a storage bay and a cooker accessory. Expect to burn through small cylinders faster.

Both are on our list of the best ice fishing heaters, as pick 1 and pick 4. The Portable Buddy also faces the Little Buddy, and the FLEX goes up against the Hunting Buddy.

The two Buddy heaters side by side

Numbers come from the Mr. Heater manuals and product pages. The FLEX spec sheet gives its weight as 11.02 without naming the unit, so the table rounds it to about 11 lb.

FeatureMr. Heater Portable Buddy MH9BXMr. Heater Buddy FLEX MH11BFLEX
Heat outputTwo steps, 4,000 and 9,000 BTU/hrDial from 8,000 to 11,000 BTU/hr
Rated heating areaUp to 225 sq ftUp to 275 sq ft
Fuel and cylindersA 1 lb cylinder, or a Buddy hose to a 20 lb tank kept outdoorsIdentical options
Run time per 1 lb3 to 6 hours (manual)1.5 to 3.5 hours (manual)
Run time per 20 lb tank48 to 110 hours36 to 72 hours
IgnitionPiezo spark, no batteriesPulse ignition on one AAA battery (included)
SafetyOxygen sensor plus tip-over cut-off, CSA 4.98Oxygen sensor plus tip-over cut-off, sold as indoor-safe
Fresh-air vent needed9 sq in minimum11 sq in, high and low
Lowest working temperatureNot stated; run time drops below 20 °F0 °F in the manual’s spec table
WeightAbout 10.6 lbAbout 11 lb
Price band$$$$
Warranty3 years limited per its product page, 1 year per the policy page3 years limited per its product page

Heat output and shelter size

Turn the FLEX dial and you get anywhere from 8,000 to 11,000 BTU, enough for a rated 275 sq ft. The Portable Buddy offers 4,000 or 9,000 BTU and a rating of 225 sq ft, so the FLEX gives you roughly a fifth more heat at the top.

The bottom end matters too. The FLEX never drops below 8,000 BTU, close to the Portable Buddy’s high, so in a small flip-over it can be more heat than you want. The Portable Buddy idles at 4,000 BTU.

A hub that seats three with gear spread out leans toward the FLEX, while a two-person hub is well served by either. Our guide to shelter types matches heater size to flip-overs, hubs and shacks.

Round goes to the Buddy FLEX, for the bigger shelter.

Fuel and run time per cylinder

A small cylinder lasts 3 to 6 hours in the Portable Buddy but only 1.5 to 3.5 in the FLEX, going by the two manuals. Mr. Heater’s FLEX page says 2 hours at full output, which matches the arithmetic for 11,000 BTU against roughly 22,100 BTU in the cylinder.

Bar chart of hours of heat from one pound of propane for the five heaters, from the high to the low setting
Hours per 1 lb cylinder from the manuals: the solid bar is the high setting, the pale bar how far low stretches it. Below 20 °F, small cylinders deliver less.

On a 20 lb tank the gap stays, 48 to 110 hours for the Portable Buddy against 36 to 72 for the FLEX. Both take the same Buddy hoses, and the tank always stays outside the shelter.

If you plan a full day on 1 lb cylinders, the FLEX means carrying twice as many. Our 20 lb tank and hose guide explains which hoses need the F273699 fuel filter and which do not.

The Portable Buddy takes this round comfortably.

Lighting and cold-weather behavior

The Portable Buddy lights with a piezo spark and needs no batteries at all. The FLEX uses pulse ignition on one AAA battery, which comes in the box, so a spare cell belongs in your tackle bag.

The FLEX manual lists 0 °F as its lowest working temperature. The Portable Buddy manual gives no floor, but both carry the Buddy warning that run times drop sharply below 20 °F, and both point you to a 20 lb tank in that weather.

Owners of the Portable Buddy report a pilot that wind or an open door can blow out, plus pilot trouble after a few seasons. We found few long-term ice reports on the FLEX, so its behavior over many winters is less known.

Round goes to the Portable Buddy, which has no battery to fail.

Safety, venting and moisture

Both shut down on low oxygen or a tip. Both manuals list fishing huts among approved spaces. The Portable Buddy manual cites CSA 4.98, while the FLEX pages we read name no standard and Mr. Heater sells it as indoor-safe outside Massachusetts and Canada.

Venting differs only a little, 11 sq in split high and low for the FLEX against 9 sq in for the Portable Buddy. Neither ODS detects carbon monoxide, so a battery CO alarm stays on the shelter wall. Our carbon monoxide guide explains why.

Burning propane releases water vapor, and the hotter FLEX burns more of it per hour. Expect more frost on the roof of a sealed hub, which our condensation guide tackles with the same vents that keep you safe.

Round goes to neither, a draw.

Storage bay, cooker and other extras

The FLEX is the modular one. A small gear compartment is built in, and the MH8CFLEX cooker clips on along with other FLEX accessories, a draw for anglers who like a hot lunch on the ice.

Use that cooker for food and nothing else, since a pan on the heater face is off limits. In the hand the FLEX feels larger than the Portable Buddy, owners say, even though the listed weights are close at about 11 lb and 10.6.

The Portable Buddy has no extras, only a handle, a burner and two settings. Many owners call it the default shanty heater for exactly that reason.

Round goes to the Buddy FLEX, for the storage bay and cooker.

Price band and value

Both sit in the $$ band, $100 to $180. The Portable Buddy often lists lower and sometimes slips under $100 at other sellers, while the FLEX usually sits higher in the band, with occasional promotions.

Each shows a 3-year limited warranty on its product page. Since the Portable Buddy costs less and burns less fuel, it stays cheaper to run over a season of weekends.

Round goes to the Portable Buddy.

The FLEX’s catch is fuel. Since a small cylinder lasts it only 1.5 to 3.5 hours, it works best on a 20 lb tank outside, and its long-term record on the ice is still thin.

The Portable Buddy’s catch is its ceiling. At 9,000 BTU it can struggle in a large hub on a windy subzero day, and then even the FLEX is a modest step up.

Simple or modular, your shelter decides

For a hub that seats two or three, our choice is the Portable Buddy, since it lights without batteries and makes a cylinder last. Choose the Buddy FLEX if your hub is larger and the storage bay and cooker fit the way you fish.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Portable Buddy and the Buddy FLEX

Is the Buddy FLEX warmer than the Portable Buddy?

Yes, at the top end. The FLEX runs from 8,000 to 11,000 BTU and is rated for up to 275 sq ft, against 9,000 BTU and 225 sq ft for the Portable Buddy. The Portable Buddy can idle lower, at 4,000 BTU.

How long does the Buddy FLEX run on a 1 lb cylinder?

Expect 1.5 to 3.5 hours from the manual’s figures, or about 2 hours flat out according to Mr. Heater’s page. With the Portable Buddy getting 3 to 6 hours from the same cylinder, many FLEX owners switch to a bulk tank set outdoors.

Does the Buddy FLEX need batteries?

Only for lighting. Its pulse ignition uses one AAA battery, included in the box. The Portable Buddy lights with a piezo spark and needs no battery.

Can I cook on the Buddy FLEX?

Only with the Buddy FLEX Cooker accessory designed for it. Never put food or a pan on the heater face, and follow the accessory manual on where it may be used.

Do both heaters work with the same 20 lb tank hose?

Yes, either heater connects to an outdoor 20 lb tank with a Buddy hose. Pick the 10 ft F273704 and you can skip the filter, but the F273701 or F273702 must be paired with an F273699 filter.