Mr. Heater Hunting Buddy, the middle step heater

The Hunting Buddy is sold to deer hunters, but its 6,000 and 12,000 BTU settings fill the gap between the Portable Buddy and the Big Buddy for ice anglers. We did not use one ourselves, so this review leans on the Mr. Heater manual and owner reports, and it says plainly where the facts run out.

Mr. Heater Hunting Buddy MH12HB propane radiant heater with a ceramic burner face The middle step

Price band $$$100 to $180 · Check the seller and return terms on the listing

Our verdict

The Hunting Buddy is a sensible middle step, with a 6,000 BTU low for a small shelter and a 12,000 BTU high for a mid-size hub. It carries the same ODS, tip-over switch and CSA 4.98 approval as the Portable Buddy, and its manual lists fishing huts. We could not pin down its price or its warranty, so check both on the listing before you buy. For most anglers the Portable Buddy or the FLEX is the better-documented choice.

Strengths

  • Two settings, 6,000 and 12,000 BTU
  • Rated for up to 300 sq ft, second only to the Big Buddy here
  • ODS, tip-over switch and CSA 4.98 approval
  • Manual lists fishing huts among approved enclosures
  • Fold-down handle that owners like

Weaknesses

  • Only 1.5 to 3.5 hours per 1 lb cylinder
  • Price band is our estimate and the warranty is unconfirmed
  • Bigger and heavier than the Portable Buddy
  • The manual gives two different vent sizes
  • Pulse ignition depends on an AA battery

Buy it if

you fish a mid-size hub where the Portable Buddy runs short on heat and the Big Buddy feels like too much heater to haul.

Skip it if

you want every spec and the warranty confirmed before you pay, or you fish alone in a small flip-over.

Specs: Mr. Heater Hunting Buddy MH12HB

TypePortable radiant propane heater
Heat output6,000 or 12,000 BTU/hr
Rated heating areaUp to 300 sq ft per Mr. Heater
FuelOne 1 lb cylinder, or a 20 lb tank kept outside on a Buddy hose
Run time per 1 lb cylinder1.5 to 3.5 hours per the manual; 20 lb tank 36 to 72 hours
IgnitionBattery pulse ignition, 1 × AA
SafetyLow-oxygen shut-off (ODS), tip-over switch, CSA 4.98; the manual lists fishing huts
Fresh-air vent needed12 sq in per the manual’s spec page (its troubleshooting page says 9)
Cold weatherRun time drops sharply below 20 °F; 20 lb tank recommended
AltitudeMay shut off above 7,000 ft
WeightAbout 16 lb on retailer listings (may be the shipping weight)
ExtrasTwo side storage compartments (manual)
Price band$$ is our estimate; check the listing
WarrantyNot confirmed

Data from the manufacturer’s manual and product page and from US retailers. Price band $$: $100 to $180. Only the price Amazon shows at checkout counts.

12,000 BTU for the gap between two Buddies

Mr. Heater rates the Hunting Buddy at 6,000 or 12,000 BTU per hour and says it heats up to 300 sq ft. In our lineup only the Big Buddy covers more floor, at 450 sq ft.

That makes it the middle step. The Portable Buddy tops out at 9,000 BTU, while the Big Buddy jumps to 18,000 and needs two cylinders or a tank to get there. The Hunting Buddy reaches its high setting on a single 1 lb cylinder.

The 6,000 BTU setting suits a two-person shelter on a mild day, and 12,000 BTU earns its keep in a hub with three anglers or a stiff wind. Our guide on heat for flip-overs, hubs and shacks matches heater size to each kind of shelter.

If you want to run the numbers for your own hub, our ice shelter BTU guide walks through floor area, wind and wall thickness. Rated area is a starting point, never a promise on an open lake.

Bar chart of the rated heating area of the five ice fishing heaters in square feet
Rated heating areas from the makers assume a closed, insulated space. On open ice in the wind, a fabric shelter needs more heat than the label suggests.

About two hours on high from a 1 lb cylinder

Per the manual, a 1 lb cylinder lasts 1.5 to 3.5 hours, high to low. A cylinder holds roughly 22,100 BTU, so 12,000 BTU an hour empties it in under two hours, and 6,000 in a little over three and a half.

For a full day, a 20 lb tank on a Buddy hose is the sensible setup, and the manual rates it at 36 to 72 hours. The F273704 hose needs no filter, and the F273701 or F273702 hoses need the F273699 filter, changed yearly.

Keep the tank and spare cylinders outside the shelter and out of the sun, and swap cylinders with the heater off. PHMSA forbids refilling the 1 lb DOT-39 cylinders, whatever an adapter kit promises.

Below 20 °F the cylinder sets the limit

The Hunting Buddy manual repeats the warning found in every Buddy manual. Continuous running below 20 °F cuts run time sharply, and a 20 lb tank is recommended instead of a 1 lb cylinder.

Propane’s boiling point sits near −44 °F, yet a small cylinder under heavy draw chills itself and frosts long before that. On high the Hunting Buddy pulls harder than the Portable Buddy, so its cylinder frosts sooner.

Wipe the frost off, let the cylinder rest or move to the tank, which holds enough liquid to keep the pressure up. Mr. Heater also warns that Buddy heaters may burn dimmer and shut off above 7,000 ft, which matters on high-country reservoirs.

AA pulse ignition and a fold-down handle

Ignition is battery pulse ignition from one AA cell, per the manual, rather than the single piezo click of the Portable Buddy. A cold battery is a weak battery, so keep a spare in a warm pocket.

Hunters like the fold-down handle and the camo version, which is sold as a separate listing. On the ice the handle matters more than the color, since a folding handle helps when you pack a sled.

There are two settings, not a variable knob. You choose low or high and manage the rest with the door and the vents, which is plain but hard to get wrong with cold fingers.

The same safety kit as the Portable Buddy

The Hunting Buddy carries a low-oxygen shut-off (ODS), a tip-over switch and CSA 4.98 approval, and its manual lists fishing huts among the approved enclosures. Mr. Heater calls the US model indoor-safe, while a Canadian listing marks its version as not indoor-safe.

The manual is less tidy on venting. Its spec page asks for 12 sq in of fresh-air opening and its troubleshooting section says 9, so go with the larger figure and split it between a vent near the roof and one near the floor.

Its ODS is an oxygen sensor with no way to detect CO, and the Minnesota DNR warns against trusting it. Hang a battery CO alarm, keep the heater clear of fabric walls and gear, and never sleep with it running.

Drafts from the door can trip the pilot on any Buddy heater. If yours keeps going out, our guide to a heater pilot that won’t stay lit covers the usual fixes before you blame the ODS.

What we could not confirm

Several facts about this heater stay open. Retailers list the part number as F232035, which we could not confirm with Mr. Heater, and an older listing for a Hunting Buddy with a fan still turns up on Amazon.

The price band is our estimate. We place it in the $$ band, between $100 and $180, but we could not read a current US retailer price, so check the listing before you decide.

The warranty is not confirmed either. Other Buddy heaters show a 3-year limited warranty on their product pages, while Mr. Heater’s general policy page says 1 year.

The weight is fuzzy too. Retailers give 16 lb and 16 by 15.5 by 10.25 in, which may be shipping figures, so the heater itself may weigh less. Owners agree it is bigger and heavier than the Portable Buddy.

Owners report steady, quiet heat

Owner themes are thin, and most come from hunting blinds rather than ice shelters. Listing summaries at Tractor Supply and Sportsman’s Guide are generally positive, praising quiet, steady heat for blinds and shanties.

The complaints are short 1 lb run time on high and a bulkier body than the Portable Buddy. We found no pattern of failures, but sourcing this thin means we cannot rule one out.

Against the Portable Buddy, the FLEX and the Big Buddy

The Portable Buddy is lighter, better documented and our top pick for two- and three-person hubs. The Buddy FLEX sits just below at 8,000 to 11,000 BTU and adds a storage bay and a cooker option.

The Big Buddy is the step up for large hubs and wheelhouse-style shelters. Our look at who makes the best ice fishing heater explains why Mr. Heater fills most of this list, and where Clam fits in.

You can see the Hunting Buddy on our shortlist next to the other five, or open our full ice fishing heater comparison for the specs in one table.

A middle step, with some homework

If the Portable Buddy leaves your hub cold and the Big Buddy is more heater than you want to drag, the Hunting Buddy fills the gap. Check the price and warranty on the listing first, then run it from a 20 lb tank outside with a CO alarm close by.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Mr. Heater Hunting Buddy

Is the Mr. Heater Hunting Buddy safe in an ice shelter?

Mr. Heater calls the US model indoor-safe, it has an ODS and a tip-over switch, and the manual lists fishing huts. You still need a vent high and a vent low, a battery CO alarm, and clear space around the heater.

How long does the Hunting Buddy run on a 1 lb cylinder?

Mr. Heater’s manual puts it at 1.5 hours on high up to 3.5 on low. Run it from a 20 lb tank outdoors via a Buddy hose and you get 36 to 72 hours.

How much venting does the Hunting Buddy need?

The manual’s spec page says 12 sq in and its troubleshooting section says 9. Use the larger figure and split it between a high vent and a low vent.

What warranty does the Hunting Buddy have?

We could not confirm it. Other Buddy heaters show a 3-year limited warranty on their product pages, while Mr. Heater’s policy page says 1 year, so check the listing.

Should I buy the Hunting Buddy or the Portable Buddy for ice fishing?

The Portable Buddy suits a two- or three-person hub and is the better-documented heater. Pick the Hunting Buddy if you need more than 9,000 BTU but not the size of a Big Buddy.