Portable Buddy or Big Buddy heater for your ice shelter

These are the two Mr. Heater models most ice anglers end up choosing between. The Portable Buddy is our top pick, the Big Buddy our heater for big hubs, and the right one depends far more on your floor area than on which is better.

Portable Buddy for most shelters, Big Buddy for the big hub

If you fish from a flip-over or a two- to three-person hub, the Portable Buddy is the one to buy. If your shelter is a big hub or a wheelhouse-style setup well past 225 sq ft, the Big Buddy earns its extra weight.

The two share more than they differ. Both are radiant propane heaters from Mr. Heater, each guarded by an ODS and a tip-over switch, and fishing huts appear in both manuals’ lists of approved spaces. The Portable Buddy cites CSA 4.98 and the Big Buddy cites ANSI Z21.103, the camp heater standard.

They sit as pick 1 and pick 2 in our ice fishing heater comparison. The rounds below follow the questions that decide it on the ice.

The two Buddies, spec by spec

Portable Buddy MH9BXBig Buddy MH18B
Heat output4,000 or 9,000 BTU/hr4,000, 9,000 or 18,000 BTU/hr
Rated area225 sq ft450 sq ft
FuelOne 1 lb cylinder, or one 20 lb tank outsideUp to two 1 lb cylinders, or up to two outdoor 20 lb tanks
Run time, 1 lb3–6 hours (manual)1.5–6 hours on one, 3–12 on two
Run time, 20 lb tank48–110 hours24–108 hours
IgnitionPiezo sparkPiezo igniter
SafetyODS, tip-over switchODS, tip-over switch
Vent needed9 sq in minimum18 sq in at ceiling and floor
WeightAbout 10.6 lb17.1 lb per Mr. Heater (some listings: 13)
FanNoneNone on the current F274805
Price band$$, sometimes under $100$$, some retailers higher
Warranty3-year limited on the product page3-year limited on the product page

Mr. Heater’s general warranty policy page says 1 year for both, so read the terms on your listing.

Heat and shelter size

The Big Buddy doubles both numbers, 18,000 BTU against 9,000 and 450 sq ft against 225. Owners report it heats large hubs to shirt-sleeve comfort on high.

Look at the settings, though. The Big Buddy’s low and medium are 4,000 and 9,000 BTU, the same two settings the Portable Buddy has, so in a small hub it mostly runs as a heavier Portable Buddy.

Our BTU guide for ice shelters shows how to size from floor area, wind and outside temperature. Past roughly 225 sq ft, or in hard wind, the third setting starts to matter.

Round goes to the Big Buddy, for any shelter past 225 sq ft.

Bar chart of the rated heating area of the five ice fishing heaters in square feet
Rated heating areas from the makers assume a closed, insulated space. On open ice in the wind, a fabric shelter needs more heat than the label suggests.

Fuel and run time

A 1 lb cylinder holds about 22,100 BTU. At 9,000 BTU an hour that is roughly 2.5 hours of burn, so the Portable Buddy’s 3 to 6 hours leans on the low setting.

The Big Buddy’s high setting only works with two 1 lb cylinders or a bigger tank, per Mr. Heater’s FAQ. On high it burns cylinders fast, and most owners run it from a 20 lb tank outside the shelter.

A 20 lb tank holds around 432,000 BTU, which matches the 24 hours the manual gives for the Big Buddy on high. The Portable Buddy stretches the same tank to 48 hours or more.

Round goes to the Portable Buddy, for lighter fuel use.

Cold weather

Both manuals carry the same warning. Run times drop sharply below 20 °F on 1 lb cylinders, and Mr. Heater recommends a 20 lb tank in those conditions.

Both take the same hoses. The F273704 hose runs without a filter. The shorter F273701 and longer F273702 call for an F273699 filter that you swap yearly.

The Big Buddy can draw from two tanks at once, which helps on long days in deep cold. Above 7,000 ft either one can dim and cut out, which rarely matters on northern lakes.

Round is a draw.

Safety and venting

The safety hardware is the same, ODS and tip-over switch. The vent is not, because the Portable Buddy needs at least 9 sq in and the Big Buddy 18 sq in at both ceiling and floor level.

A bigger heater burns more oxygen and makes more moisture, so you need bigger openings and must keep snow off them. Owners of both report that wind or an opened door can blow out the pilot.

The ODS senses oxygen, not carbon monoxide. Carry a battery CO alarm with either heater and keep the Portable Buddy’s 30 in above and 24 in in front free of fabric and gear.

Round is a draw, with bigger vents for the Big Buddy.

Weight and carrying

The Portable Buddy weighs about 10.6 lb. The Big Buddy weighs 17.1 lb per Mr. Heater, with a 19 × 12 in footprint, and owners call it heavy and bulky for a walk out by hand.

Neither has a fan or needs batteries in its current form. Older Big Buddy units had a battery blower, so reviews that mention fan noise or drained batteries describe those.

Round goes to the Portable Buddy.

Price and value

Both sit in the $$ band. The Portable Buddy sits near the $100 line and some sellers drop it below, while some retailers list the Big Buddy high enough to push it past $180.

Paying for 18,000 BTU you never use buys only weight. Paying less and shivering in a big hub is no saving either.

Round goes to the Portable Buddy, unless your shelter needs the third setting.

Which one should you buy?

Choose the Portable Buddy for a flip-over or a hub up to about 225 sq ft. It is our top pick for that reason, and it carries easily.

Choose the Mr. Heater Big Buddy MH18B for big hubs and wheelhouse-style shelters, especially if you already run a 20 lb tank. The Big Buddy review covers it in depth.

If neither fits, the Hunting Buddy and Buddy FLEX sit between them. Our guide to ice fishing heater brands shows the whole Buddy family next to the Clam alternatives.

Bigger is not safer or warmer in a small shelter. A Big Buddy on high in a two-person hub overheats the roof air and burns oxygen faster than a small vent can replace it.

Size the heater to the floor, crack the vents top and bottom, and keep the 20 lb tank outside the shelter on its hose.

Which Buddy fits your shelter

For most anglers the Portable Buddy is enough heater, lighter to carry and easier on fuel. If your hub tops 225 sq ft or the wind never lets up, the Big Buddy’s third setting pays for its weight.

Questions and answers

More questions about the Portable Buddy and Big Buddy

Is the Big Buddy twice as warm as the Portable Buddy?

On high, yes. The Big Buddy puts out 18,000 BTU against 9,000 and is rated for 450 sq ft against 225. Its low and medium settings match the Portable Buddy’s two settings, 4,000 and 9,000 BTU.

Can the Big Buddy run on high from one 1 lb cylinder?

No. Mr. Heater says one 1 lb cylinder supports only the low and medium settings. High needs two 1 lb cylinders or a larger tank kept outside the shelter on a hose.

How long does a 20 lb tank last in each heater?

The Portable Buddy manual gives 48 to 110 hours on a 20 lb tank. The Big Buddy manual says 24 to 108 hours from a single 20 lb tank, and 48 to 216 hours with two connected.

Which one needs more ventilation?

The Big Buddy. Its manual calls for 18 sq in of opening both up high and down low, twice the 9 sq in minimum the Portable Buddy manual asks for. Carry a battery CO alarm with either.

Is the Big Buddy too heavy to carry onto the ice?

Mr. Heater lists it at 17.1 lb, against about 10.6 lb for the Portable Buddy, and owners call it bulky for walking out by hand. On a sled or in a wheelhouse it matters far less.